Thursday, October 10, 2013

WEEK2 - EOC: Supreme Court


   Hill has a truly unique case. He was convicted of murdering his girlfriend. He was then convicted of beating his prison cellmate to death. At the time of his trial, he was unable to prove his mental retardation beyond a reasonable doubt (a high burden uniquely imposed in Georgia alone), as the government’s experts all felt that he was either malingering or competent.

     All of those experts later changed their diagnoses, citing inexperience and insufficient time with Hill for proper evaluation. All seven experts who have examined him now agree that he is, beyond a doubt, mentally retarded.

     I believe that Hill although being mentally retarded still has to fallow the laws of the American people. He is not crazy, or have multi personality disorder, that may lead him to do something without clearly knowing what he is doing.  Even Though he is mentally retarded he should still have an understanding of good and bad.

No comments:

Post a Comment